• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

BEAUTY + KIND

Cruelty Free + Vegan Beauty Guide

  • CRUELTY-FREE BRANDS
  • VEGAN BRANDS
  • BRANDS THAT TEST
  • Organic Brands
  • Natural Brands
  • DIY Beauty
  • Shop
    • Makeup
    • Skin Care
    • Body Care Products
    • Hair Products
    • Tools
    • Fragrance
  • Show Search
Hide Search
You are here: Home / animal testing / Is Maybelline Cruelty Free or Not? [2020 Update]

Is Maybelline Cruelty Free or Not? [2020 Update]

BEAUTY and KIND · October 6, 2020 · Leave a Comment

Is Maybelline cruelty free

If you love Maybelline cosmetics and living a cruelty free life you now need to read this now!

Unfortunately, you now need to find cruelty free makeup and skin care alternatives to replace Maybelline if you want to live an ethical lifestyle. Maybelline is on our list of brands that test on animals.

We’ll show you why, and the misleading disclosure gaps in their animal testing policy.

We’ll also show you how to fix this ethical dilemma, and how to find the best Maybelline cruelty free and vegan alternatives.

… so let’s dive in.

is Maybelline Cruelty free?

Maybelline is NOT a cruelty-free brand. They sell their cosmetics in mainland China where the law requires animal testing. Maybelline does disclose this fact in their animal testing policy.

Quick guide show
is Maybelline Cruelty free?
Maybelline Cruelty Free Mascara Alternatives
Does Maybelline test on animals?
Maybelline Cruelty Free Foundation Alternatives
Maybelline Animal Testing Policy
Maybelline Cruelty Free Lipstick Dupes
Corporate Parent Testing Policy
Maybelline Cruelty Free Concealer Alternatives
Does Maybelline sell in China?
Maybelline Cruelty Free Eyeliner Dupes
Do maybelline’s Ingredient Suppliers Test on Animals?
Here is what we found on supplier testing
What disclosure is missing
Maybelline Eyeshadow Dupes that are Cruelty Free
Is MAYBELLINE Vegan Friendly?
Common animal-derived ingredients
Our Vegan Shopping Advice
Who owns MAYBELLINE Brand?
More MAYBELLINE Cosmetics Cruelty-Free FAQS
Is MAYBELLINE cruelty free in the US?
Is MAYBELLINE on Peta’s Cruelty Free List?
Is MAYBELLINE on Leaping Bunny Approved cruelty-free list?
Is MAYBELLINE Animal Friendly?
Is MAYBELLINE Cruelty-Free and Vegan?
MAYBELLINE Cosmetics cruelty-free Summary
Why we don’t consider MAYBELLINE a cruelty-free brand
Our Cruelty-Free Standard
MAYBELLINE Cruelty-Free and vegan Alternatives
Certified Cruelty Free
Certified Vegan
Certified Natural
Certified Organic
DIY Clean Beauty
Should You switch to kinder beauty brands?
How to make the Switch to Animal-Friendly Brands

Maybelline Cruelty Free Mascara Alternatives

Stop using mascara that’s tested on animals by swapping to any of these Maybelline dupes:

  • IT Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing and Lengthening Mascara Super Black 0.30 oz/ 9 g
    IT Cosmetics Superhero Elastic Stretch Volumizing and Lengthening Mascara Super Black 0.30 oz/ 9 g
    $25.00
  • Too Faced Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara Standard Size Black - 0.27 oz/ 8 mL
    Too Faced Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara Standard Size Black – 0.27 oz/ 8 mL
    $26.00
  • ILIA Mini Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara After Midnight .1 oz/ 3g
    ILIA Mini Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara After Midnight .1 oz/ 3g
    $13.00
  • tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes™ 4-in-1 Mascara Black 0.24 oz/ 7 mL
    tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes™ 4-in-1 Mascara Black 0.24 oz/ 7 mL
    $23.00

Does Maybelline test on animals?

Yes, Maybelline cosmetics are tested on animals in Mainland China or where required by law. Maybelline clearly says this in their cosmetic product safety disclosure.

…but it makes us wonder if animal testing is more wide-spread?

What’s not so clear is if ingredients are tested on animals. How they phrase the Maybelline animal testing policy does not clearly answer this question.

…this part gets interesting… but before we dive into this issue – let’s explore the actual testing policy.

Maybelline Cruelty Free Foundation Alternatives

  • Urban Decay Stay Naked Weightless Foundation 10CP 1.0 fl oz/ 30 mL
    Urban Decay Stay Naked Weightless Foundation 10CP 1.0 fl oz/ 30 mL
    $39.00
  • Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Liquid Touch Weightless Foundation 100W 1 oz/ 30 mL
    Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Liquid Touch Weightless Foundation 100W 1 oz/ 30 mL
    $29.00
  • KVD Vegan Beauty Lock-It Foundation Deep 66 C 1 oz/ 30 mL
    KVD Vegan Beauty Lock-It Foundation Deep 66 C 1 oz/ 30 mL
    $37.00
  • IT Cosmetics Your Skin But Better Foundation + Skincare Tan Warm 44 1 oz/ 30 mL
    IT Cosmetics Your Skin But Better Foundation + Skincare Tan Warm 44 1 oz/ 30 mL
    $39.50

Maybelline Animal Testing Policy

Here is the full Maybelline Animal Testing policy disclosed on their website:

Maybelline does not disclose an animal testing policy.
Maybelline does not disclose an animal testing policy for it’s brand [BIG RED FLAG]

Maybelline Cruelty Free Lipstick Dupes

  • Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Lipstick Allison 0.11 oz/ 3.2 g
    Anastasia Beverly Hills Liquid Lipstick Allison 0.11 oz/ 3.2 g
    $20.00
  • HUDA BEAUTY Power Bullet Matte Lipstick Honeymoon 0.10 oz/ 3 g
    HUDA BEAUTY Power Bullet Matte Lipstick Honeymoon 0.10 oz/ 3 g
    $25.00
  • KVD Vegan Beauty Everlasting Liquid Lipstick Roxy 0.22 oz/ 6.6 mL
    KVD Vegan Beauty Everlasting Liquid Lipstick Roxy 0.22 oz/ 6.6 mL
    $21.00
  • Charlotte Tilbury Hot Lips Lipstick 2 Glowing Jen
    Charlotte Tilbury Hot Lips Lipstick 2 Glowing Jen
    $37.00

Corporate Parent Testing Policy

Maybelline is owned by L’Oreal who also sells in China and submits to animal testing in China. Here is their testing policy… pay close attention to the yellow highlighted section:

L’Oreal Animal Testing Policy – see yellow highlighted exception disclosing they permit animal testing on a wide range of cosmetics in Mainland China.

So this is the spot where many brands start to mislead consumers with omission of key facts.

Even though Maybelline as a brand is silent on testing… they also don’t disclose if their ingredients are tested on animals by suppliers.

BTW… in case you didn’t know… most animal testing occurs at the ingredient level, and not the product level.

…So avoiding this topic is not cool, and is not a complete disclosure on animal testing facts.

More on this in a bit… first we need to talk about testing in China.

Maybelline Cruelty Free Concealer Alternatives

  • MILK MAKEUP Flex Concealer Caramel 0.2 oz/ 5.9 mL
    MILK MAKEUP Flex Concealer Caramel 0.2 oz/ 5.9 mL
    $28.00
  • Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Liquid Touch Brightening Concealer 120C 0.25 oz/ 7.5 mL
    Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Liquid Touch Brightening Concealer 120C 0.25 oz/ 7.5 mL
    $19.00
  • Too Faced Born This Way Super Coverage Multi-Use Concealer Mahogany 0.50 oz
    Too Faced Born This Way Super Coverage Multi-Use Concealer Mahogany 0.50 oz
    $30.00

Does Maybelline sell in China?

Yes, Maybelline does sell in Mainland China. Brands that sell in mainland China are subject to animal testing laws which require their products to be test on animals.

Screenshot of Maybelline China website selling cosmetics in China

Maybelline puts profits ahead of ethics. Maybelline is willing to allow testing of their products in China to access this huge marketplace. China is one of their fastest and largest growing consumer markets.

Maybelline Cruelty Free Eyeliner Dupes

  • tarte Sex Kitten Eyeliner Black 0.007 oz/ 0.21 mL
    tarte Sex Kitten Eyeliner Black 0.007 oz/ 0.21 mL
    $20.00
  • KVD Vegan Beauty Cake Pencil Eyeliner Trooper Black 0.3g/ 0.011 oz
    KVD Vegan Beauty Cake Pencil Eyeliner Trooper Black 0.3g/ 0.011 oz
    $20.00
  • Charlotte Tilbury Rock 'N' Kohl Eyeliner Pencil Barbarella Brown .04 oz
    Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl Eyeliner Pencil Barbarella Brown .04 oz
    $27.00

Do maybelline’s Ingredient Suppliers Test on Animals?

So… the next step in our investigation dives into Maybelline’s ingredient testing policies.

What we really want to know is if any animal testing happens on Maybelline ingredients…anywhere.

Does the Maybelline animal testing policy prohibit the testing of ingredients and raw materials on animals?

Here is what we found on supplier testing

What we discovered is Maybelline does not fully disclose if animal testing happens on their ingredients or raw materials provided by suppliers.

What we like about their animal testing policy is the fact they use non-animal forms to test the final product cosmetic:

Maybelline does not disclose if their ingredients are tested on animals.

What disclosure is missing

We would like to see Maybelline disclose if any 3rd parties or suppliers test on their ingredients or raw materials before they receive them.

…Is this too much to ask?

Many cruelty free brands now choose to take an ethical stand and do not test on animals anywhere in their supply chain. Brands serious about cruelty free cosmetics will certify with 3rd parties and provide explicit statements ensuring no testing has occurred on their products or ingredients by either them or their suppliers.

Unfortunately, Maybelline is not a brand that has committed 100% to eliminating all animal testing across their supply chain, or alternatively, providing more explicit disclosure on this controversial topic.

Maybelline Eyeshadow Dupes that are Cruelty Free

  • Charlotte Tilbury Darling Eyeshadow Palette 0.19 oz/ 5.4 g
    Charlotte Tilbury Darling Eyeshadow Palette 0.19 oz/ 5.4 g
    $57.00
  • Too Faced Natural Eyes Eyeshadow Palette
    Too Faced Natural Eyes Eyeshadow Palette
    $39.00

Is MAYBELLINE Vegan Friendly?

Maybelline is not vegan. They do not provide vegan labelling on products, nor are they certified as vegan with either Leaping Bunny or Peta. It is likely some of their products contain animal-derived ingredients, as these are often less expensive to source as cosmetic ingredients.

It’s safe to assume that if a brand has not declared vegan status they allow the use of animal-derived ingredients in their formulations. Most brands are not vegan because it’s much more expensive to source and manage vegan raw materials through supply chains.

Common animal-derived ingredients

Ingredients that are often sourced from animals include:

  • Hyaluronic Acid – often found in serums and moisturizers
  • Retinol – found in some night creams
  • Carmine – often found in blush and lipstick
  • Stearic Acid – found in skin creams
  • Glycerin – a humectant found in many moisturizers
  • Lanolin – in some moisturizers
  • Lactic Acid – found in some Alpha Hydroxy Acids (AHAs)
  • Beeswax – often found in lipstick and lip balms
  • Animal hair – used in makeup brushes
  • Guanine – can be used in nail polish and eye shadow
  • Keratin – in hair and nail products
  • Squalene – in moisturizers, eye creams and facial oils

The bottom line with vegan cosmetics is it’s really difficult to tell from the ingredient list if the source is animal or synthetic versions. As shoppers we can only rely on vegan labelling, certification and other disclosures offered by the brand.

Our Vegan Shopping Advice

If a product is not advertised and labelled as 100% vegan you should assume it contains animal-derived ingredients.

We also want to understand if the entire brand is vegan… or just select products.

For ethical reasons many people now only use vegan products from a brand that is 100% vegan and free of animal ingredients.

Who owns MAYBELLINE Brand?

Maybelline is a large cosmetics brand owned by L’Oreal who is a large cosmetics conglomerate. L’Oreal is not cruelty-free.

L’Oreal owns more than 25 other popular beauty and cosmetic brands such as NYX, Garner, and Essie.

More MAYBELLINE Cosmetics Cruelty-Free FAQS

Is MAYBELLINE cruelty free in the US?

No, as they do not verify if ingredient suppliers test on animals.

Is MAYBELLINE on Peta’s Cruelty Free List?

No, Maybelline has not certified with Peta as either cruelty-free or vegan.

Is MAYBELLINE on Leaping Bunny Approved cruelty-free list?

No, Maybelline has not certified with Leaping Bunny as either cruelty-free or vegan.

Is MAYBELLINE Animal Friendly?

No, Maybelline Cosmetics is not animal friendly as it tests on animals in China and may use animal-derived ingredients in its formulations.

Is MAYBELLINE Cruelty-Free and Vegan?

No, Maybelline is not cruelty-free or vegan because it tests on animals in China, uses animal-derived ingredients, and does not label products as vegan.

MAYBELLINE Cosmetics cruelty-free Summary

Here is a summary of Maybelline’s cruelty-free assessment. Maybelline is not a cruelty-free brand at this time. To become cruelty-free Maybelline would have to stop selling in countries that require animal testing and only use ingredients from suppliers that do not test on animals.

Tests finished products on animals? Yes, when required by law
Tests ingredients on animals? Unclear
Suppliers test on animals? Unclear
Leaping Bunny Certified?No
Peta Certified?No
Uses animal-derived ingredients?Likely
Vegan? No
Sold in Mainland China? Yes
Parent company? L’Oreal
Are all parent company brands cruelty-free? No
Based on our research of Maybelline they are not cruelty-free or vegan. We recommend switching to any of these cruelty-free brands.

Why we don’t consider MAYBELLINE a cruelty-free brand

To start with, there is no legal definition for the claims of “cruelty-free” or “not tested on animals” that are used by cosmetic brands.

The most common definition for “cruelty-free” is that a product or its ingredients were not tested on animals.

Where this gets murky is when brands only talk about their direct testing activities, and omit facts about 3rd party animal testing that may take place on their products or ingredients.

We don’t consider Maybelline to be cruelty-free because they allow their products to be tested on animals in China. They are also silent on ingredient testing by others in their animal testing disclosure.

Our Cruelty-Free Standard

At Beauty + Kind our standard for “cruelty-free” and “not tested on animals” is very simple. We require brand disclosure that no animal testing has occurred during any part of bringing their product to market by any party. This includes testing on raw materials, ingredients, finished products or selling in countries where animal testing is required by law.

Beauty + Kind

Unfortunately Maybelline does not meet our Beauty + Kind highest standard due to their China animal testing and lack of vegan formulations.

MAYBELLINE Cruelty-Free and vegan Alternatives

If your looking to switch to more ethical brands, here are some cruelty-free and vegan options to consider:

Certified Cruelty Free

Take the guess work out of it and browse the ultimate list of cruelty free makeup and skin care brands.

Certified Vegan

Easily find brands that certify they don’t use animal-derived ingredients on the list of vegan makeup and skin care brands.

Certified Natural

Learn more about brands using natural formulations on the ultimate list of natural makeup and skin care brands.

Certified Organic

Discover brands focused on botanicals and organics on the ultimate list of organic makeup and skin care brands.

DIY Clean Beauty

Have some fun creating clean beauty formulations from the ultimate list of DIY makeup and skin care recipes.

Should You switch to kinder beauty brands?

Our philosophy and Beauty + Kind is that TRUE CRUELTY-FREE BEAUTY means that no harm to animals has happened during the entire manufacturing and testing process. This includes the source and harvest of ingredients, ingredient testing, and testing of the final product.

How to make the Switch to Animal-Friendly Brands

Making the switch is easier than you think once you have the right information. If you want to switch to more ethical and animal-friendly beauty brands check out the ultimate list of vegan and cruelty-free brands.

animal testing    Brands

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

What can we help you find?

Shop Cruelty Free by Category

Latest Shopping Guides

Cosmetic Animal Testing Statistics

25 Horrifying Cosmetic Animal Testing Statistics for 2021

vegan lip balm list

The 23 Best Vegan Lip Balm Picks to Soothe Dry Lips

15 Exquisite Vegan and Cruelty Free Body Washes for 2020

Trending Right Now

  • Hum Nutrition Glow Sweet Glow Hum Nutrition Glow Sweet Glow $25.00
  • Herbivore Botanicals Coco Rose Coconut Oil Body Polish Herbivore Botanicals Coco Rose Coconut Oil Body Polish $36.00
  • Youth To The People Superfood Air-Whip Moisturizer with Hyaluronic Acid 2 oz/ 60 mL Youth To The People Superfood Air-Whip Moisturizer with Hyaluronic Acid 2 oz/ 60 mL $48.00
  • MILK MAKEUP Matcha Cleanser 1 oz/ 28 g MILK MAKEUP Matcha Cleanser 1 oz/ 28 g $28.00
  • Laurel Whole Plant Unburden Serum Laurel Whole Plant Unburden Serum $88.00
  • Josie Maran Whipped Argan Oil Body Butter 8 oz Unscented 8 oz/ 237 mL Josie Maran Whipped Argan Oil Body Butter 8 oz Unscented 8 oz/ 237 mL $36.00
  • LANCER Skincare Caviar Lime Acid Peel 1.7 oz/ 50 mg LANCER Skincare Caviar Lime Acid Peel 1.7 oz/ 50 mg $95.00
  • BeautyBio GloPRO® Microneedling Facial Regeneration Tool BeautyBio GloPRO® Microneedling Facial Regeneration Tool $199.00
  • Nourish Organics Lavender Mint Hydrating Body Lotion Nourish Organics Lavender Mint Hydrating Body Lotion $14.99
  • OLEHENRIKSEN Sheer Transformation® Perfecting Moisturizer 1.7 oz/ 50 mL OLEHENRIKSEN Sheer Transformation® Perfecting Moisturizer 1.7 oz/ 50 mL $40.00
  • Drunk Elephant Virgin Marula Luxury Face Oil 1 oz/ 30 mL Drunk Elephant Virgin Marula Luxury Face Oil 1 oz/ 30 mL $72.00
  • Odacite PERFECT NUTRIENTS BODY LOTION Odacite PERFECT NUTRIENTS BODY LOTION $50.00
  • Glow Recipe Watermelon + AHA Glow Sleeping Mask 2.7 oz/ 80 mL Glow Recipe Watermelon + AHA Glow Sleeping Mask 2.7 oz/ 80 mL $45.00
  • Drunk Elephant C-Firma™ Vitamin C Day Serum 1 oz/ 30 mL Drunk Elephant C-Firma™ Vitamin C Day Serum 1 oz/ 30 mL $80.00
  • PMD Personal Microderm Pro Blush PMD Personal Microderm Pro Blush $199.00
  • Drunk Elephant Protini™ Polypeptide Moisturizer 1.69 oz/ 50 mL Drunk Elephant Protini™ Polypeptide Moisturizer 1.69 oz/ 50 mL $68.00
  • Drunk Elephant Sili™ Body Lotion 8.0 oz/ 240 mL Drunk Elephant Sili™ Body Lotion 8.0 oz/ 240 mL $20.00
  • Dr. Barbara Sturm Hydrating Face Mist 1.7 oz/ 50 mL Dr. Barbara Sturm Hydrating Face Mist 1.7 oz/ 50 mL $95.00
  • Herbivore Botanicals Blue Tansy AHA + BHA Resurfacing Clarity Mask Herbivore Botanicals Blue Tansy AHA + BHA Resurfacing Clarity Mask $48.00
  • Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm 1.7 oz/ 50 mL Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm 1.7 oz/ 50 mL $22.00
  • Alima Pure Concealer Alima Pure Concealer $15.00
  • dyson Supersonic Hair Dryer Iron/ Fuchsia dyson Supersonic Hair Dryer Iron/ Fuchsia $399.00
  • bareMinerals COMPLEXION RESCUE™ Tinted Moisturizer with Hyaluronic Acid and Mineral SPF 30 Opal 01 1.18 oz bareMinerals COMPLEXION RESCUE™ Tinted Moisturizer with Hyaluronic Acid and Mineral SPF 30 Opal 01 1.18 oz $33.00
  • Buxom Full-On™ Plumping Lip Polish Gloss Kimberly 0.15 oz/ 4.44 mL Buxom Full-On™ Plumping Lip Polish Gloss Kimberly 0.15 oz/ 4.44 mL $21.00
  • Moroccanoil Dry Shampoo Dark Tones 5.4 oz/ 205 mL Moroccanoil Dry Shampoo Dark Tones 5.4 oz/ 205 mL $26.00
  • Dr. Barbara Sturm Clarifying Acne Spot Treatment 0.5 oz/ 15 mL Dr. Barbara Sturm Clarifying Acne Spot Treatment 0.5 oz/ 15 mL $55.00
  • amika Hair Blow Dryer Brush amika Hair Blow Dryer Brush $100.00
  • Hum Nutrition Red Carpet - Glowing Skin & Hair Hum Nutrition Red Carpet - Glowing Skin & Hair $25.00
  • Hourglass Unreal™ High Shine Volumizing Lip Gloss Enchant 0.20 oz/ 5.6 g Hourglass Unreal™ High Shine Volumizing Lip Gloss Enchant 0.20 oz/ 5.6 g $30.00
  • Youth To The People Superberry Hydrate + Glow Dream Mask with Vitamin C 2 oz/ 59 mL Youth To The People Superberry Hydrate + Glow Dream Mask with Vitamin C 2 oz/ 59 mL $48.00
  • NuFACE Mini Facial Toning Device Original NuFACE Mini Facial Toning Device Original $199.00
  • REN Clean Skincare Moroccan Rose Otto Body Lotion 6.8 oz/ 200 mL REN Clean Skincare Moroccan Rose Otto Body Lotion 6.8 oz/ 200 mL $46.00
  • GLO Science GLO Lit™ At-Home Teeth Whitening Device Kit White GLO Science GLO Lit™ At-Home Teeth Whitening Device Kit White $149.00
  • Herbivore Botanicals PRISM 20% AHA + 5% BHA Exfoliating Glow Facial Herbivore Botanicals PRISM 20% AHA + 5% BHA Exfoliating Glow Facial $58.00
  • KORA Organics Noni Glow Face Oil Mini 0.34 oz/ 10 mL KORA Organics Noni Glow Face Oil Mini 0.34 oz/ 10 mL $25.00
  • Youth To The People Kombucha + 11% AHA Exfoliation Toner with Lactic Acid 4 oz/ 118 mL Youth To The People Kombucha + 11% AHA Exfoliation Toner with Lactic Acid 4 oz/ 118 mL $38.00
  • KVD Vegan Beauty Tattoo Eyeliner Mad Max Brown 0.019 oz/ 0.55 mL KVD Vegan Beauty Tattoo Eyeliner Mad Max Brown 0.019 oz/ 0.55 mL $21.00
  • Herbivore Botanicals Rose Quartz De Puffing Face Roller Herbivore Botanicals Rose Quartz De Puffing Face Roller $40.00
  • Charlotte Tilbury Collagen Lip Bath Gloss Pillow Talk 0.26 oz / 7.9 mL Charlotte Tilbury Collagen Lip Bath Gloss Pillow Talk 0.26 oz / 7.9 mL $35.00
  • Farmacy Deep Sweep 2% BHA Pore Cleaning Toner with Moringa + Papaya 4.0 oz/ 120 mL Farmacy Deep Sweep 2% BHA Pore Cleaning Toner with Moringa + Papaya 4.0 oz/ 120 mL $28.00

Product categories

  • Body Care Products (365)
  • Fragrance (6)
  • Hair Products (379)
  • Makeup (1730)
  • Skin Care (972)
  • Tools (297)

Follow Beauty + Kind

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • About
  • Privacy
  • Terms of Use
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact

JOIN THE CAUSE

Our mission is to help you live a kind and cruelty free life. Get the inside scoop on the best cruelty free and vegan brand offers by joining our EXCLUSIVE KIND e-mail tribe. Stay in the know with the latest beauty hacks, trends, bonus offers and discount codes offered by leading vegan and cruelty free beauty brands. Read More…

© 2021 · BEAUTY + KIND